Want a say in Hedge End on EVERY vote in Parliament? ‘Direct Digital Democracy' could be for You!
By Caroline_W | Thursday, March 18, 2010, 17:29
An independent intending to stand in the general election in Hackney South and Shoreditch, East London, is promising to use ‘Direct Digital Democracy’ if elected and vote the way the majority of his constituents want each time there’s a vote in Parliament.
-
Photo of the Houses of Parliament by SaffyH from Flickr
Would you like the opportunity to make your views in Hedge End felt on every issue voted on in Westminster?
Danny de la Haye has set up a website called Getavote and on which he promises to put a poll for every vote coming up in Parliament. He says, ‘Every voter living in Hackney South and Shoreditch will have a login for the site, and will be able to vote in the polls using their computer or their mobile phone. Whatever the majority vote is, I will vote that way.’
Do you think this could work – and work here in Hedge End?
Is a system like this open to abuse – hacking? Or voters registering more than once? Or the views of cranks?
Could you trust the elected MP to be true to the polls’ results?
Danny de la Haye specifies three occasions on which he’ll vote not in accordance with a poll result – if it would mean him voting against improving equality, civil liberties, and democracy. Is this effectively a ‘get out of jail free card’?
And would the average voter have time to mug up on all the information required to make a balanced decision on every vote to be taken in Parliament?
Would it mean that rather than selecting an MP who would best represent the interests of the constituency as a whole ‘Direct Digital Democracy’ would result in the few that could be bothered representing (and not necessarily with best interests at heart) the apathetic majority.
Or is it really a means of extending a say in the running of the country to the people?
We’d love to hear your views at Hedgeendpeople!
Photo of the Houses of Parliament by SaffyH from Flickr.
Comments
Actually I´m not sure I agree with that.
I think this sort of voting would appeal more to the younger generation, and I think too that they are perhaps less likely to be found on Hedge End People. On the other hand if you look at the statistics for the social networking site Facebook (which seems to be evermore expanding!) there are currently over 400 million users worldwide and 13.7 of these are from the UK. That is a lot of people! If publicity targets the right people I think this sort of voting could be a useful addition, although not replacement to the current voting system.
By EdwinaKing at 09:17 on 22/03/10
ReportThere are currently 244 people registered with HedgeEndPeople, out of a population of many thousands...
That nicely illustrates the problem.
E-democracy might be "cool", but it is not representative...
By TGRWorzel at 15:46 on 21/03/10
ReportIt´s a different option I must say, and what with voting levels apparently at an all time low maybe this would encourage more people to take part. Perhaps it is time to open our minds to some more unusual forms of voting seeing as the conventional form doesn´t maybe seem to cut it anymore.
By EdwinaKing at 14:44 on 21/03/10
ReportThere is a big problem with this idea.
Contrary to popular opinion, not everybody is connected to the Internet, or minded to participate in such consultation exercises. And what's to stop multiple votes distorting the result....?
Witness these numerous TV top ten polls, all done via phone & internet voting. It seems the greatest musical of all time was something thoroughly forgettable featuring somebody called Eminem, apparently....!
Lesson = Musn't use internet and phone voting to the exclusion of the more traditional forms of consultation....
By TGRWorzel at 20:08 on 18/03/10
Report